6 min read#website-redesign#mistakes#small-business

Redesign Mistakes That Cost Businesses Customers

Common website redesign mistakes, such as changing addresses without redirects or hiding contact details, and how to avoid each one.

A redesign feels like a fresh start, and that is exactly why it is risky. The excitement tends to focus on how the new site looks, while the things that quietly brought customers in get lost along the way. Here are the mistakes that show up again and again, with a way to avoid each.

Changing addresses without leaving a trail

Every page on your current site has an address. Search engines have seen it, customers may have saved it, and other websites may link to it. When a redesign changes those addresses and nothing points the old ones to the new ones, every one of those paths leads to an error page.

Before you change anything, make a list of your current pages and note which ones matter most: the home page, the services pages, the contact page and anything people regularly ask about. For each page that moves, plan a redirect, which is an instruction that sends visitors from the old address to the new one.

Ask whoever is building the new site to confirm that redirects are part of the plan. If they are not sure what you mean, that is useful information. It is much easier to arrange this before launch than to repair lost visibility afterward.

Hiding the contact path

Designers love clean pages with lots of white space, and that can be a fine goal. It becomes a problem when the phone number moves into a menu, the booking button shrinks, or the contact form hides three clicks deep.

Look at your old site and note where a customer could reach you without searching. Then check that the new design offers at least the same, and ideally easier. A visitor should be able to find a way to contact you within a few seconds of arriving, on a phone, without hunting.

A simple test helps. Hand your phone to a friend, open the new design, and ask them to find your phone number and your hours. Watch their thumb. If it wanders, the design is hiding something.

Throwing away good wording

A redesign often brings a rewrite, and rewrites often swap clear, specific sentences for polished, vague ones. Your old site may contain wording that already does a good job: the way you describe a service, the answers to questions customers always ask, the line that sounds like you.

Before you start, copy out the parts of your text that work. You can recognize them because customers repeat them back to you, or because they answer a question you get weekly. Keep these, even if the layout around them changes.

Here is a worked example of keeping specific wording during a redesign. It uses an invented business.

Before the redesign: “We fix leaking taps, blocked drains and broken water heaters in Example Town, usually the same day. Call before noon and we will do our best to come today.”

A redesign that lost it: “Delivering excellence in plumbing solutions.”

A redesign that kept it: “Leaking taps, blocked drains and broken water heaters, fixed in Example Town. Call before noon and we will do our best to come today.”

The third version can sit in a beautiful new layout and still say something a customer can use.

Building something heavy and slow

New designs often add large images, animated effects and extra features. Each addition can slow the page, and a slow page costs you the visitor on a weak connection. This is easy to miss when you test on a fast computer with a good network.

Test the new design on a phone with an ordinary connection. Pay attention to how long it takes before you can read the first screen and tap the main button. If you notice the wait, a customer will too.

Ask whether every new feature earns its place. An animation that delights you in the first week may only irritate people who simply want your opening hours. Keep what helps the visitor do something, and trim what only decorates.

Launching without testing

The last mistake is rushing from approval to launch. A redesigned site has many moving parts: forms, links, menus, images, titles and mobile layouts. Any of them can break during a rebuild.

Before launch, run a short test. Submit every form and confirm it reaches the right inbox. Click through the whole menu. Open the site on a phone and a different browser. Check that the hours, address and phone number are correct. Then ask someone who has not seen the site to try a simple task, such as finding your service area.

If possible, keep a copy of the old site available for a while. If something goes wrong, you will want a way to compare, and perhaps to put things back.

Common mistakes

Redesigning without a reason. A fresh look is not a goal. Decide what is not working, such as unclear wording or a hard-to-find phone number, and make sure the redesign addresses it.

Skipping the page inventory. If you do not know which pages matter, you cannot protect them.

Letting taste override clarity. What looks elegant to you may leave a visitor unsure where to tap.

Forgetting the small print. Privacy notes, opening hours for holidays and contact details are easy to drop during a rebuild.

Changing everything at once. If results drop after a big change, you will not know which part caused it.

Try this today

  1. Write a list of your current pages and mark the five that matter most to your customers.
  2. Copy out three sentences from your current site that are clear and specific, and decide where they will live in any redesign.
  3. Ask your designer or builder, in writing, how old addresses will be redirected to new ones.

Field notes

  • Plan redirects before changing any page address.
  • Keep the contact path at least as easy as it was before.
  • Save wording that already works and carry it into the new design.
  • Test the new site on a phone with an ordinary connection.
  • Run a full test of forms, links and details before launch.

Prefer to hand the work off? Describe your business to websiites and review the finished site before choosing a plan. The pricing page lists what each plan includes.